The telling line in the replies is this one: "I might need to ask myself whether you really can have censorship resistance without fungibility. THIS is the question we need to be asking." That is the whole argument. A coin a blacklist can refuse is not the same coin. Cash does not care where the bill was. Bitcoin does. Monero does not.
Also hard not to notice: a lot of the fungibility talk over there is from anons. Either Stacker accounts with a reputation are uncomfortable saying this under their own name, or some of us went over and said the quiet part?
The telling line in the replies is this one: "I might need to ask myself whether you really can have censorship resistance without fungibility. THIS is the question we need to be asking." That is the whole argument. A coin a blacklist can refuse is not the same coin. Cash does not care where the bill was. Bitcoin does. Monero does not.
Also hard not to notice: a lot of the fungibility talk over there is from anons. Either Stacker accounts with a reputation are uncomfortable saying this under their own name, or some of us went over and said the quiet part?