I have been using Simplex Chat for over 2 years now, and I am positively biased towards it. However, in writing this brief review, I considered the challenges the average whatsapp user may face.
The CompanyThe Company
There is a Ltd behind it, but they have worked hard to ensure a level of independence from venture capital and rely on a business model based on crowdfunding plus free for personal use + paid for business. The positive thing is that the company owner is active in multiple SimpleX groups and answers many questions. You can also contact the developers directly into the app, and they promptly respond. Github repository and security audit here.
OnboardingOnboarding
First hurdle: no central server means no search for users based on phone numbers or ID. Every user will have to actively get in touch with all their contacts and exchange links to connect. The possibility of generating multiple incognito profiles (a bit like Monero subaddresses) can be equally a bit daunting for the new user. Incognito profiles are optional, so you can stick with one profile and be ok, though. However, because you have no identifier on the SimpleX network, nobody can contact you unless you share a link/QR code: this benefits the user's privacy.
RelaysRelays
Relays are inherently slower than a central server, so the entire experience feels more like nostr than whatsapp. You may have to wait a few seconds up to a minute to get all the messages relayed to you, depending also on how many contacts or groups you have, and whether you proxy to TOR. On the good side, you won't have to manage relays, unless you wish to switch to some onion ones or move to your self-hosted relays. No data is stored on central servers or relays (after delivering the messages), and the entire bulk of your chats rests in a local encrypted database.
Audio/Video CallsAudio/Video Calls
I don't do many of these, so I can't say much on the quality. I have done a few audio calls and they have all been consistently clear and smooth. It really depends on which relays you use and their load at the time. If you consider using it for frequent audio/video calls, I'd recommend your self-hosted relay.
GroupsGroups
Group management is easy and with all the basic features you'd expect. Incognito profiles come in handy for groups, where you can use one for every group and noone can track your activity across groups. Besides, once you leave the group, your incognito profile disappears, giving you an extra layer of privacy: basically you cannot be "harassed" once you leave a group. There is also a Telegram bridge for groups, which should ease the transition to Simplex.
In conclusion, the problem with messaging apps is always the same vicious circle - you only want to use them if you know your social circle is using them. And in this case , it is even worse cause the lack of central server means you can't even find people in there. So you must actively work to get people onboard to give them a reason to use it. It is hard, when you talk to the average Joe Bloggs, who doesn't understand why he should stop using his beloved whatsapp/telegram/signal.
Alternative solution to SimpleXAlternative solution to SimpleX
There is a middle ground solution, though, that allows people to enhance their privacy witbout having to ditch their favorite messaging apps altogether. Kryptos is a digital keyboard that encrypts all the text written in your current messaging or email. You still need to exchange keys with your contact(s), but you won't need to cut all the bridges with whatsapp or telegram.
The fact that the only discovery method though is the manual one where you exchange links or QR codes also prevents any sort of spam from being able to contact you.
Sure, you can spam in public groups, but if the group administrators are on it, like they should be, then the spam should be removed.
good write up. the discoverability of simplex is the biggest challenge.
if anyone can drop QR codes for good simpleX instances that would be cool
Thanks for the review!