pull down to refresh

Thanks for sharing: this is exciting, especially since floppy.md (the guy building it) is no vibecoder, to say the least lol :))
Just tweeted it to help bring more eyes to the project:
https://x.com/themerit0crat/status/2122386385793359962 original ↗

TThe Meritocrat@themerit0crat

Kuroshio: an L2 payment channel / pool protocol for Monero FCMP++ / Carrot (research prototype atm). A group of users can hold funds in a single output under an n-of-n FROST key. No operator, no trusted party.kuroshio.monster/ twitter.com/1440000bytes/status/2121848632739819960

These guys still retain the advantage of knowing how to code themselves to be able to manually review/edit that code to higher standards though - @untraceable

^^ this is not vibecoding :)

this is LLM-assisted coding (or whatever you want to call it).

do you really think he wrote that by hand ? - @spirobel

No one expects anything written by hand (with drip pen and parchment) lol :))

I face a permanent dilemma:
either start every post with formal definitions and turn it into a mathematically precise academic paper complete with Lean certificate (which no one will read coz it's boring, I know this from firsthand experience)...
or skip the definitions for social media and guarantee that someone, somewhere, will misread it and get upset…

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

reply

oracle bone script only like the real OG's :)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oracle_bone_script
( to be clear I mean this not the database company )

on a serious note: L2's are not the right approach. Scaling the L1 is the way.

reply
we should focus more on...

as a die-hard 𝖼̶𝖺̶𝗍̶ individualist I never think in "we should" terms.
If someone skilled is doing something beneficial for the ecosystem (like L2) they actually want to do (and not even asking for anything in return), I welcome it. High-skill & high-agency people either do what they want, or they stop (e.g. because of the negative feedback) and go do something else they want more, and there’s zero guarantee that "something else" will be scaling L1 on even anything for Monero.

e.g. some people who (groundlessly!!) suspect I have skills beyond memes and get mildly annoyed that I'm not applying them to whatever they currently rank as higher priority for the ecosystem. I just do what I want (and what I have capacity for without heavy commitment), like a cat that hangs around and occasionally catches vermin and community/household benefits from it, but a cat does it only because a cat wants to catch mice, and remains perfectly free to stay or leave on its own terms :)

(*Cats were never really domesticated the way other animals were; their DNA barely changed: https://arstechnica.com/science/2017/06/cats-are-an-extreme-outlier-among-domestic-animals )

Once you run a project other people actually use/rely on, it becomes more like a baby: now you have a moral responsibility to sustain it and can't just walk away whenever you feel like it.

*(well, you can, ofc, if you’re an a-hole who doesn't give a f*ck about the people who trusted you e.g. https://monero.forum/thread/can-anyone-explain-whats-going-moneroforum-lately or if @untraceable decides tomorrow to shut down stasher.news that would be a real bummer).

reply

i like your cat analogy and the other ones a lot. the whole "i do what i want and stay free to leave" thing is funny and kinda based. but i think my therapist would have said that you suffer from some commitment issues. and no one here actually said anything about the L2 project itself.
that monero.forum thread you linked is fucking bullshit. admin just vanished, swap dead, zero announcement, zero explanation, people left hanging. so yeah the person behind a project in monero is way more important than the code.

reply

Thankfully stasher news is open source. If stasher news shut down, I would hope someone else would just spin another one up to take its place.

Hopefully stasher news is decentralized by that point and it wouldn't matter who the admin is.

reply

L2's are bitcoin cat cafe bullshit

when we talk about cats, we really need to ask what kind of cat?
here look at this video that shows a house cat getting torn to pieces after it fell into a lion's cage https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=thYHQFZL82U original ↗

we are that lion.

right now the differences are not as pronounced, as we are not grown yet. all just small felines. at some point that changes. there is one group of people that will take over the financial system and there is one that decided to build a kitten cafe right next to it.

i belong to the first group. i care about the second group the same way, the cat cares about the mice it catches. they not like us. sure its good to nurture. but not every crippled idea

Bitcoin is a kitten cafe thanks to this ideology. Instead of carrying the mission out to the end, they spend their time with these goofy botched on ideas that fracture liquidity & lead to centralization.

What ever you focus on you will become. life is short. I am not going to put on a kitten maid costume and live in an L2 kitten cafe like the bitcoiners. That is not my nature

reply

fair enough, most people just use the term vibecode to mean any ai generated code regardless of the process. I assumed thats what you meant.

reply

hate to break it to you but every dev vibecodes now. there is just no good reason left do to everything by hand, and they wouldn't be able to keep up with the pace of advancement with hand written code only. AI can break it faster than you can write it. These guys still retain the advantage of knowing how to code themselves to be able to manually review/edit that code to higher standards though.

Ffloppy.md@1440000bytes

You wont be surprised I fucked the whole world with 20 dollar and got defense access from Anthropic

reply

do you really think he wrote that by hand ?

we should focus more on scaling the L1. There is no reason to believe the outcome of a Monero L2 will come out better than Lightning.

frost, fcmp and carrot are nice, throwing them together can still not erase the fundamental downsides of L2's

L2's are a distraction from the original mission of building p2p digital cash. Hot keys on servers, fractured liquidity, there are so many caveats to these approaches ...

reply