found this. every decade they invent a new thing that's supposed to kill us all that never happened. starting to think ai fud is just this generation's version of the same old fud. in 20 years people will probably laugh at how hard everyone was losing their minds over it and call it the same overblown bullshit we call global cooling and y2k now. feels like every generation just gets a new thing to be scared of so they stay controlled. or is this time actually different?
pull down to refresh
related posts
AI is feared, but often for the wrong reasons IMO. I fear its compromise by the state, its censorship, its use in surveillance tools by the state. I think the sentient AI or take all the jobs fears are actually advertised by AI companies to attract investment dollars or to attract regulation so they can attempt to use it to monopolize the tech.
I agree. I think what we should fear isn't AI itself, but states using it against us with no restrictions. On top of that, even if the whole "AI will take all the jobs" thing turns out to be true, I think it's an unnecessary fear. To me, most existing jobs are already made up just so stupid people can work somewhere and keep the unemployment rate looking low (especially government jobs).
Definitely. A lot of bullshit jobs that mostly exist to give corporations leverage as they collude with government to regulate or bully the smaller companies out of business. Large corporations are just bureaucracies acting as litigious gangsters. Most would be dead in 5 years without their lobbyists and lawyers rigging the game.
Both can be true at the same time. Same way a real exploit or a real zero-day is real. If you leave the door open it can and will hurt people. That part is not pure FUD. Treating it like pure fantasy is just the other side of the same coin.
What is also real is that politicians will "never waste a good crisis." The actual problem becomes the pretext for the control they already wanted. They will overblow it through the corporate media and use it.
So yes -- the danger can be genuine. And yes -- they will use it. The two things do not cancel each other out.
Fear that AI will cause human extinction or end of the world: 0.1%
Fear that Government will use that as an excuse to surveil and control the population: 99.9%
I think the vast majority of it is fear porn. No doubt, AI is breaking things and finding exploits that have been in code for years and years and years, but it's also helping to fix them. We have accumulated a lot of technical debt over the past 40 years, and only now is the bill truly coming due
Honestly I think it's the y2k question that matters, just not the way people ask it. I've been running a dozen or so ai agents as my memory and paperwork layer for about 9 months now, and nothing from the fear porn has come anywhere close to biting me. What bites is boring as hell. A model confidently mishearing one of my sentences and writing the opposite of what I said into my own notes. One citing a line past the end of the actual file it was reviewing. Real incidents, all of them, plumbing failures not the terminator.
Y2K wasn't the apocalypse, it was bad date code, and it really did almost hurt the people who never bothered checking... and nobody checked. That's exactly where ai is right now, except the bad date code is a model that's confidently wrong, and the people not checking are wiring it into hiring, medical, their whole paperwork lives with zero verification layer under it.
So no, I don't think it's global-warming-panic level fake. The sci-fi fear is the porn, the boring risk is already here, it just doesn't sell merch. The fix isn't banning the robot, it's the harness. Receipts, cross checks from brains that weren't trained on the same lineage, human sign off on anything with consequences. Boring answer... but boring stuff is what's still standing 20 years later when the fear decade gets laughed at.